(VAR x y z) (RULES f(f(x, y), z) -> f(x, f(y, z)) f(a1, y) -> y f(a2, y) -> y f(a3, y) -> y f(a4, y) -> y f(a5, y) -> y f(a6, y) -> y f(a7, y) -> y f(a8, y) -> y f(a9, y) -> y f(a10, y) -> y f(a11, y) -> y f(a12, y) -> y f(x, i1(x)) -> a1 f(x, i2(x)) -> a2 f(x, i3(x)) -> a3 f(x, i4(x)) -> a4 f(x, i5(x)) -> a5 f(x, i6(x)) -> a6 f(x, i7(x)) -> a7 f(x, i8(x)) -> a8 f(x, i9(x)) -> a9 f(x, i10(x)) -> a10 f(x, i11(x)) -> a11 f(x, i12(x)) -> a12 ) (COMMENT Example 3.9 in \cite{SK90})