YES We show the termination of the TRS R: |app'|(|app'|(eq(),|0|()),|0|()) -> true() |app'|(|app'|(eq(),|0|()),|app'|(s(),x)) -> false() |app'|(|app'|(eq(),|app'|(s(),x)),|0|()) -> false() |app'|(|app'|(eq(),|app'|(s(),x)),|app'|(s(),y)) -> |app'|(|app'|(eq(),x),y) |app'|(|app'|(le(),|0|()),y) -> true() |app'|(|app'|(le(),|app'|(s(),x)),|0|()) -> false() |app'|(|app'|(le(),|app'|(s(),x)),|app'|(s(),y)) -> |app'|(|app'|(le(),x),y) |app'|(|app'|(app(),nil()),y) -> y |app'|(|app'|(app(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)),y) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(app(),x),y)) |app'|(min(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),nil())) -> n |app'|(min(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x))) -> |app'|(|app'|(if_min(),|app'|(|app'|(le(),n),m)),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x))) |app'|(|app'|(if_min(),true()),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x))) -> |app'|(min(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)) |app'|(|app'|(if_min(),false()),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x))) -> |app'|(min(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) |app'|(|app'|(rm(),n),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(rm(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_rm(),|app'|(|app'|(eq(),n),m)),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_rm(),true()),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(rm(),n),x) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_rm(),false()),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),m),|app'|(|app'|(rm(),n),x)) |app'|(|app'|(minsort(),nil()),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(minsort(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)),y) -> |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_minsort(),|app'|(|app'|(eq(),n),|app'|(min(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)))),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)),y) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_minsort(),true()),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)),y) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(minsort(),|app'|(|app'|(app(),|app'|(|app'|(rm(),n),x)),y)),nil())) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_minsort(),false()),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)),y) -> |app'|(|app'|(minsort(),x),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),y)) |app'|(|app'|(map(),f),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(map(),f),|app'|(|app'|(add(),x),xs)) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),|app'|(f,x)),|app'|(|app'|(map(),f),xs)) |app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),|app'|(|app'|(add(),x),xs)) -> |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(|app'|(filter2(),|app'|(f,x)),f),x),xs) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(|app'|(filter2(),true()),f),x),xs) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),x),|app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),xs)) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(|app'|(filter2(),false()),f),x),xs) -> |app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),xs) Instead we prove termination of the uncurried system: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: |app'|#(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2#(x1,y) p2: |app'|#(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2#(x1,y) p3: |app'|#(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2#(x1,y) p4: |app'|#(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4#(x1,x2,x3,y) p5: |app'|#(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2#(x1,y) p6: |app'|#(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3#(x1,x2,y) p7: |app'|#(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3#(x1,x2,y) p8: |app'|#(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2#(x1,y) p9: |app'|#(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2#(x1,y) p10: |app'|#(min_0(),y) -> min_1#(y) p11: |app'|#(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2#(x1,y) p12: |app'|#(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2#(x1,y) p13: eq_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2#(x,y) p14: le_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2#(x,y) p15: app_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> app_2#(x,y) p16: min_1#(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2#(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) p17: min_1#(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> le_2#(n,m) p18: if_min_2#(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1#(add_2(n,x)) p19: if_min_2#(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1#(add_2(m,x)) p20: rm_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3#(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) p21: rm_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> eq_2#(n,m) p22: if_rm_3#(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2#(n,x) p23: if_rm_3#(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2#(n,x) p24: minsort_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3#(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) p25: minsort_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> eq_2#(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))) p26: minsort_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> min_1#(add_2(n,x)) p27: if_minsort_3#(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2#(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0()) p28: if_minsort_3#(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> app_2#(rm_2(n,x),y) p29: if_minsort_3#(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> rm_2#(n,x) p30: if_minsort_3#(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2#(x,add_2(n,y)) p31: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p32: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> map_2#(f,xs) p33: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4#(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) p34: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p35: filter2_4#(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) p36: filter2_4#(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: {p3, p4, p9, p31, p32, p33, p34, p35, p36} {p24, p27, p30} {p15} {p20, p22, p23} {p13} {p16, p18, p19} {p14} -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p2: |app'|#(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2#(x1,y) p3: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> map_2#(f,xs) p4: |app'|#(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4#(x1,x2,x3,y) p5: filter2_4#(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) p6: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p7: |app'|#(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2#(x1,y) p8: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4#(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) p9: filter2_4#(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r35, r36, r37 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: map_2#_A(x1,x2) = x2 add_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 5 |app'|#_A(x1,x2) = x2 map_1_A(x1) = x1 filter2_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = x1 + x2 + x3 filter2_4#_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = x4 false_0_A() = 34 filter_2#_A(x1,x2) = x2 filter_1_A(x1) = x1 |app'|_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 1 true_0_A() = 56 le_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 31 |0|_0_A() = 25 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 3 map_2#!_A(x1,x2) = 16 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 17 |app'|#!_A(x1,x2) = 16 map_1!_A(x1) = 16 filter2_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = 22 filter2_4#!_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = 15 false_0!_A() = 13 filter_2#!_A(x1,x2) = 14 filter_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 15 |app'|!_A(x1,x2) = 21 true_0!_A() = 44 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 20 |0|_0!_A() = 45 s_1!_A(x1) = 47 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: map_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 45} add_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 43 |app'|#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 81} map_1_A(x1) = x1 + 36 filter2_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x1 - 19, x2 + 21, x3 - 1} filter2_4#_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = max{1, x2 - 60} false_0_A = 17 filter_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 60} filter_1_A(x1) = x1 + 80 |app'|_A(x1,x2) = max{19, x1 - 81, x2 - 81} true_0_A = 15 le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{99, x1 - 21, x2 + 14} |0|_0_A = 2 s_1_A(x1) = max{20, x1 + 1} map_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 14 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 12, x2 + 5} |app'|#!_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 21} map_1!_A(x1) = 0 filter2_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x3 - 20} filter2_4#!_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = max{0, x3 - 21, x4 - 1} false_0!_A = 436 filter_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 58 filter_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 59 |app'|!_A(x1,x2) = max{25, x1 + 2} true_0!_A = 1 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = 4 |0|_0!_A = 437 s_1!_A(x1) = 0 partial status: pi(map_2#) = [2] pi(add_2) = [1, 2] pi(|app'|#) = [2] pi(map_1) = [1] pi(filter2_3) = [2] pi(filter2_4#) = [4] pi(false_0) = [] pi(filter_2#) = [2] pi(filter_1) = [1] pi(|app'|) = [1, 2] pi(true_0) = [] pi(le_2) = [] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1, p2, p3, p4, p5, p6, p7, p8, p9 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: minsort_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3#(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) p2: if_minsort_3#(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2#(x,add_2(n,y)) p3: if_minsort_3#(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2#(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0()) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r31, r32, r33, r34, r35, r36, r37, r38, r39, r44, r45, r46, r47, r48, r54 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: minsort_2#_A(x1,x2) = 0 add_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 21 if_minsort_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = 0 eq_2_A(x1,x2) = 1 min_1_A(x1) = x1 + 3 false_0_A() = 1 true_0_A() = 1 app_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 5 rm_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 nil_0_A() = 6 |0|_0_A() = 1 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 9 le_2_A(x1,x2) = 11 if_rm_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = x3 minsort_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 5 filter_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 10 minsort_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 13 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 23 if_minsort_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = x1 + x2 + x3 + 12 eq_2!_A(x1,x2) = 41 min_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 1 false_0!_A() = 42 true_0!_A() = 40 app_2!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 8 rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 2 nil_0!_A() = 7 |0|_0!_A() = 43 s_1!_A(x1) = 43 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = 42 if_rm_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = x3 + 2 minsort_2!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 43 filter_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 41 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: minsort_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{39, x2} add_2_A(x1,x2) = 0 if_minsort_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{39, x1 - 2, x2} eq_2_A(x1,x2) = 40 min_1_A(x1) = max{77, x1 + 37} false_0_A = 40 true_0_A = 21 app_2_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 12, x2 + 53} rm_2_A(x1,x2) = max{77, x1 - 12} nil_0_A = 0 |0|_0_A = 25 s_1_A(x1) = max{44, x1 + 23} le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{78, x1 - 5} if_rm_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{77, x2 - 12, x3 + 12} minsort_2_A(x1,x2) = max{79, x1 + 26, x2 - 16} filter_2_A(x1,x2) = max{14, x2 - 1} minsort_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 25 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = 0 if_minsort_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x1 - 15, x2 + 8} eq_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{4, x1 + 2} min_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 24 false_0!_A = 26 true_0!_A = 28 app_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 12, x2 + 27} rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = 0 nil_0!_A = 7 |0|_0!_A = 27 s_1!_A(x1) = 2 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{29, x1 - 45, x2} if_rm_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x3 - 1} minsort_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{29, x2 + 12} filter_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 73} partial status: pi(minsort_2#) = [] pi(add_2) = [] pi(if_minsort_3#) = [] pi(eq_2) = [1] pi(min_1) = [1] pi(false_0) = [] pi(true_0) = [] pi(app_2) = [2] pi(rm_2) = [] pi(nil_0) = [] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(le_2) = [] pi(if_rm_3) = [] pi(minsort_2) = [1, 2] pi(filter_2) = [1] The following rules are removed: p3 -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: minsort_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3#(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) p2: if_minsort_3#(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2#(x,add_2(n,y)) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: {p1, p2} -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: minsort_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3#(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) p2: if_minsort_3#(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2#(x,add_2(n,y)) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r31, r32, r33, r34, r35, r36, r37, r44 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: minsort_2#_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 add_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 3 if_minsort_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = x2 + x3 eq_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 2 min_1_A(x1) = 3 false_0_A() = 1 |0|_0_A() = 5 true_0_A() = 6 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 5 le_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 2 rm_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 3 nil_0_A() = 3 minsort_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 4 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = 6 if_minsort_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = x2 + 2 eq_2!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 5 min_1!_A(x1) = 5 false_0!_A() = 9 |0|_0!_A() = 10 true_0!_A() = 7 s_1!_A(x1) = 13 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 8 rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = 6 nil_0!_A() = 5 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: minsort_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x1 - 21, x2 - 39} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{22, x1 - 70, x2} if_minsort_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{2, x1 - 19, x2 - 21, x3 - 39} eq_2_A(x1,x2) = max{8, x1 - 118} min_1_A(x1) = max{20, x1 - 2} false_0_A = 1 |0|_0_A = 117 true_0_A = 1 s_1_A(x1) = max{8, x1 + 1} le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{8, x1 - 118} rm_2_A(x1,x2) = max{54, x1 - 24, x2 - 24} nil_0_A = 10 minsort_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 25, x2 - 2} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{19, x1 + 17} if_minsort_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x1 - 9, x2 - 25} eq_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{89, x1 - 96} min_1!_A(x1) = max{0, x1 - 53} false_0!_A = 14 |0|_0!_A = 21 true_0!_A = 20 s_1!_A(x1) = max{15, x1 - 125} le_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{89, x2 - 124} rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{13, x1 - 97, x2 - 23} nil_0!_A = 11 partial status: pi(minsort_2#) = [] pi(add_2) = [] pi(if_minsort_3#) = [] pi(eq_2) = [] pi(min_1) = [] pi(false_0) = [] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(true_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(le_2) = [] pi(rm_2) = [] pi(nil_0) = [] The following rules are removed: p1, p2 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: app_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> app_2#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r44 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: app_2#_A(x1,x2) = x1 add_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 5 rm_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 8 nil_0_A() = 6 app_2#!_A(x1,x2) = 0 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = 7 rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = 5 nil_0!_A() = 1 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: app_2#_A(x1,x2) = 0 add_2_A(x1,x2) = 0 rm_2_A(x1,x2) = max{10, x1 - 44, x2 - 10} nil_0_A = 9 app_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 41, x2 + 41} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{39, x1 - 65, x2 - 76} rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{44, x1 - 66, x2 - 10} nil_0!_A = 0 partial status: pi(app_2#) = [1] pi(add_2) = [1, 2] pi(rm_2) = [1] pi(nil_0) = [] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: if_rm_3#(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2#(n,x) p2: rm_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3#(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) p3: if_rm_3#(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2#(n,x) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r31, r32, r33, r34 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: if_rm_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = 0 false_0_A() = 11 add_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 rm_2#_A(x1,x2) = 0 eq_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 9 true_0_A() = 11 |0|_0_A() = 2 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 3 if_rm_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = x1 false_0!_A() = 8 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 11 rm_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 10 eq_2!_A(x1,x2) = 9 true_0!_A() = 8 |0|_0!_A() = 9 s_1!_A(x1) = 10 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: if_rm_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{1, x1 - 82, x2 - 2} false_0_A = 4 add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{121, x2 - 29} rm_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 2} eq_2_A(x1,x2) = max{81, x1 - 9} true_0_A = 10 |0|_0_A = 0 s_1_A(x1) = x1 if_rm_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = 52 false_0!_A = 3 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{151, x2 + 54} rm_2#!_A(x1,x2) = 53 eq_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{177, x2 + 4} true_0!_A = 176 |0|_0!_A = 2 s_1!_A(x1) = max{0, x1 - 1} partial status: pi(if_rm_3#) = [1, 3] pi(false_0) = [] pi(add_2) = [2] pi(rm_2#) = [2] pi(eq_2) = [] pi(true_0) = [] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1, p2, p3 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: eq_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of (no rules) Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: eq_2#_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 3 eq_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 s_1!_A(x1) = 8 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: eq_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{x1, x2} s_1_A(x1) = x1 eq_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 98, x2 + 98} s_1!_A(x1) = max{96, x1 - 53} partial status: pi(eq_2#) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: if_min_2#(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1#(add_2(n,x)) p2: min_1#(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2#(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) p3: if_min_2#(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1#(add_2(m,x)) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r36, r44 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: if_min_2#_A(x1,x2) = 0 true_0_A() = 34 add_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 10 min_1#_A(x1) = 0 le_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 7 false_0_A() = 21 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 1 |0|_0_A() = 14 rm_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 12 nil_0_A() = 1 if_min_2#!_A(x1,x2) = 2 true_0!_A() = 0 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 + 3 min_1#!_A(x1) = 2 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 1 false_0!_A() = 14 s_1!_A(x1) = 15 |0|_0!_A() = 15 rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 10 nil_0!_A() = 4 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: if_min_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x2 - 60} true_0_A = 3 add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{43, x2 + 19} min_1#_A(x1) = max{1, x1 - 55} le_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 52 false_0_A = 3 s_1_A(x1) = max{34, x1 + 19} |0|_0_A = 34 rm_2_A(x1,x2) = max{62, x1 - 18, x2 + 32} nil_0_A = 93 if_min_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{31, x2 - 35} true_0!_A = 3 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 49, x2 + 28} min_1#!_A(x1) = max{2, x1 - 31} le_2!_A(x1,x2) = 48 false_0!_A = 1 s_1!_A(x1) = 87 |0|_0!_A = 4 rm_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{76, x1 - 135, x2 - 103} nil_0!_A = 50 partial status: pi(if_min_2#) = [] pi(true_0) = [] pi(add_2) = [] pi(min_1#) = [] pi(le_2) = [1, 2] pi(false_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(rm_2) = [1] pi(nil_0) = [] The following rules are removed: p1, p3 -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: min_1#(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2#(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: (no SCCs) -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: le_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(eq_0(),y) -> eq_1(y) r6: |app'|(eq_1(x1),y) -> eq_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r10: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r11: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r12: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r13: |app'|(if_min_0(),y) -> if_min_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_min_1(x1),y) -> if_min_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_minsort_0(),y) -> if_minsort_1(y) r16: |app'|(if_minsort_1(x1),y) -> if_minsort_2(x1,y) r17: |app'|(if_minsort_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_minsort_3(x1,x2,y) r18: |app'|(if_rm_0(),y) -> if_rm_1(y) r19: |app'|(if_rm_1(x1),y) -> if_rm_2(x1,y) r20: |app'|(if_rm_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_rm_3(x1,x2,y) r21: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r22: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(min_0(),y) -> min_1(y) r26: |app'|(minsort_0(),y) -> minsort_1(y) r27: |app'|(minsort_1(x1),y) -> minsort_2(x1,y) r28: |app'|(rm_0(),y) -> rm_1(y) r29: |app'|(rm_1(x1),y) -> rm_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: eq_2(|0|_0(),|0|_0()) -> true_0() r32: eq_2(|0|_0(),s_1(x)) -> false_0() r33: eq_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r34: eq_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> eq_2(x,y) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: min_1(add_2(n,nil_0())) -> n r41: min_1(add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> if_min_2(le_2(n,m),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) r42: if_min_2(true_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(n,x)) r43: if_min_2(false_0(),add_2(n,add_2(m,x))) -> min_1(add_2(m,x)) r44: rm_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: rm_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_rm_3(eq_2(n,m),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_rm_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> rm_2(n,x) r47: if_rm_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,rm_2(n,x)) r48: minsort_2(nil_0(),nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: minsort_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> if_minsort_3(eq_2(n,min_1(add_2(n,x))),add_2(n,x),y) r50: if_minsort_3(true_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,minsort_2(app_2(rm_2(n,x),y),nil_0())) r51: if_minsort_3(false_0(),add_2(n,x),y) -> minsort_2(x,add_2(n,y)) r52: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r54: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r55: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r56: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r57: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of (no rules) Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): matrix interpretation with standard point-wise order: carrier: N^1 order: standard order interpretations: le_2#_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 2 le_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + x2 s_1!_A(x1) = 51 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: le_2#_A(x1,x2) = 0 s_1_A(x1) = max{2, x1 - 101} le_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 115 s_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 116 partial status: pi(le_2#) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains.