YES We show the termination of the TRS R: |app'|(|app'|(minus(),x),|0|()) -> x |app'|(|app'|(minus(),|app'|(s(),x)),|app'|(s(),y)) -> |app'|(|app'|(minus(),x),y) |app'|(|app'|(quot(),|0|()),|app'|(s(),y)) -> |0|() |app'|(|app'|(quot(),|app'|(s(),x)),|app'|(s(),y)) -> |app'|(s(),|app'|(|app'|(quot(),|app'|(|app'|(minus(),x),y)),|app'|(s(),y))) |app'|(|app'|(le(),|0|()),y) -> true() |app'|(|app'|(le(),|app'|(s(),x)),|0|()) -> false() |app'|(|app'|(le(),|app'|(s(),x)),|app'|(s(),y)) -> |app'|(|app'|(le(),x),y) |app'|(|app'|(app(),nil()),y) -> y |app'|(|app'|(app(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)),y) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(|app'|(app(),x),y)) |app'|(|app'|(low(),n),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(low(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_low(),|app'|(|app'|(le(),m),n)),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_low(),true()),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),m),|app'|(|app'|(low(),n),x)) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_low(),false()),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(low(),n),x) |app'|(|app'|(high(),n),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(high(),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_high(),|app'|(|app'|(le(),m),n)),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_high(),true()),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(high(),n),x) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(if_high(),false()),n),|app'|(|app'|(add(),m),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),m),|app'|(|app'|(high(),n),x)) |app'|(quicksort(),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(quicksort(),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),x)) -> |app'|(|app'|(app(),|app'|(quicksort(),|app'|(|app'|(low(),n),x))),|app'|(|app'|(add(),n),|app'|(quicksort(),|app'|(|app'|(high(),n),x)))) |app'|(|app'|(map(),f),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(map(),f),|app'|(|app'|(add(),x),xs)) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),|app'|(f,x)),|app'|(|app'|(map(),f),xs)) |app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),nil()) -> nil() |app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),|app'|(|app'|(add(),x),xs)) -> |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(|app'|(filter2(),|app'|(f,x)),f),x),xs) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(|app'|(filter2(),true()),f),x),xs) -> |app'|(|app'|(add(),x),|app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),xs)) |app'|(|app'|(|app'|(|app'|(filter2(),false()),f),x),xs) -> |app'|(|app'|(filter(),f),xs) Instead we prove termination of the uncurried system: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: |app'|#(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2#(x1,y) p2: |app'|#(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2#(x1,y) p3: |app'|#(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4#(x1,x2,x3,y) p4: |app'|#(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2#(x1,y) p5: |app'|#(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3#(x1,x2,y) p6: |app'|#(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3#(x1,x2,y) p7: |app'|#(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2#(x1,y) p8: |app'|#(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2#(x1,y) p9: |app'|#(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2#(x1,y) p10: |app'|#(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2#(x1,y) p11: |app'|#(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1#(y) p12: |app'|#(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2#(x1,y) p13: minus_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2#(x,y) p14: quot_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> quot_2#(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y)) p15: quot_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2#(x,y) p16: le_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2#(x,y) p17: app_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> app_2#(x,y) p18: low_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3#(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) p19: low_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> le_2#(m,n) p20: if_low_3#(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2#(n,x) p21: if_low_3#(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2#(n,x) p22: high_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3#(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) p23: high_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> le_2#(m,n) p24: if_high_3#(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2#(n,x) p25: if_high_3#(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2#(n,x) p26: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2#(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) p27: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> quicksort_1#(low_2(n,x)) p28: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> low_2#(n,x) p29: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> quicksort_1#(high_2(n,x)) p30: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> high_2#(n,x) p31: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p32: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> map_2#(f,xs) p33: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4#(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) p34: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p35: filter2_4#(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) p36: filter2_4#(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: {p2, p3, p9, p31, p32, p33, p34, p35, p36} {p27, p29} {p17} {p22, p24, p25} {p18, p20, p21} {p16} {p14} {p13} -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p2: |app'|#(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2#(x1,y) p3: map_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> map_2#(f,xs) p4: |app'|#(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4#(x1,x2,x3,y) p5: filter2_4#(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) p6: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> |app'|#(f,x) p7: |app'|#(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2#(x1,y) p8: filter_2#(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4#(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) p9: filter2_4#(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2#(f,xs) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r48, r50, r52 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: map_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x1 - 89, x2 - 61} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{60, x1 + 4, x2} |app'|#_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x1 - 93, x2 - 59} map_1_A(x1) = max{92, x1 + 4} filter2_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x1 - 4, x2 + 9, x3 + 40} filter2_4#_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = max{2, x2 - 84, x3 - 55, x4 - 59} false_0_A = 63 filter_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x1 - 84, x2 - 59} filter_1_A(x1) = max{92, x1 + 9} |app'|_A(x1,x2) = max{65, x1 - 34} true_0_A = 10 quicksort_1_A(x1) = max{69, x1 + 7} nil_0_A = 5 map_2_A(x1,x2) = max{59, x1 - 30, x2 + 7} filter_2_A(x1,x2) = max{67, x1 - 32, x2 + 7} map_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{86, x1 - 2} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = 85 |app'|#!_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x1 - 5} map_1!_A(x1) = max{152, x1} filter2_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x2 + 150, x3 - 1} filter2_4#!_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = x2 + 3 false_0!_A = 150 filter_2#!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 3 filter_1!_A(x1) = 150 |app'|!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 152, x2 + 146} true_0!_A = 86 quicksort_1!_A(x1) = max{0, x1 - 67} nil_0!_A = 0 map_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 1, x2 - 6} filter_2!_A(x1,x2) = 149 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: map_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 131, x2 - 35} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{34, x1 + 18, x2 + 13} |app'|#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 132, x2 - 35} map_1_A(x1) = max{33, x1 + 1} filter2_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x2 + 92, x3 + 92} filter2_4#_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = max{1, x2 - 40, x3 - 40, x4 - 35} false_0_A = 30 filter_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 40, x2 - 35} filter_1_A(x1) = max{131, x1 + 124} |app'|_A(x1,x2) = 32 true_0_A = 2 quicksort_1_A(x1) = x1 nil_0_A = 83 map_2_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 - 14, x2 + 15} filter_2_A(x1,x2) = max{227, x1 - 14, x2 + 2} map_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{7, x2 - 12} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{95, x1 + 92, x2 - 132} |app'|#!_A(x1,x2) = max{8, x2 + 6} map_1!_A(x1) = max{49, x1 - 122} filter2_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x1 + 94, x2 - 148} filter2_4#!_A(x1,x2,x3,x4) = max{x3 + 16, x4 + 11} false_0!_A = 96 filter_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{10, x2 - 1} filter_1!_A(x1) = 0 |app'|!_A(x1,x2) = max{54, x1 - 34, x2 + 51} true_0!_A = 56 quicksort_1!_A(x1) = max{52, x1 + 14} nil_0!_A = 49 map_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{50, x1 - 122, x2 - 131} filter_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{97, x1 - 34, x2 - 84} partial status: pi(map_2#) = [] pi(add_2) = [] pi(|app'|#) = [] pi(map_1) = [] pi(filter2_3) = [2] pi(filter2_4#) = [] pi(false_0) = [] pi(filter_2#) = [] pi(filter_1) = [] pi(|app'|) = [1, 2] pi(true_0) = [] pi(quicksort_1) = [] pi(nil_0) = [] pi(map_2) = [1, 2] pi(filter_2) = [] The following rules are removed: p1, p2, p3, p4, p5, p6, p7, p8, p9 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> quicksort_1#(high_2(n,x)) p2: quicksort_1#(add_2(n,x)) -> quicksort_1#(low_2(n,x)) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r35, r36, r37, r40, r41, r42, r43, r44, r45, r46, r47, r50 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: quicksort_1#_A(x1) = 0 add_2_A(x1,x2) = 14 high_2_A(x1,x2) = max{160, x1 - 16} low_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 14 le_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 149 |0|_0_A = 183 true_0_A = 4 s_1_A(x1) = max{863, x1 + 518} false_0_A = 332 nil_0_A = 3 if_low_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = x2 + 14 if_high_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{160, x1 - 331, x2 - 16} map_2_A(x1,x2) = max{13, x1 - 14, x2 - 15} quicksort_1#!_A(x1) = 0 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = 177 high_2!_A(x1,x2) = 177 low_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{182, x1 - 1} le_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{181, x2 - 2} |0|_0!_A = 181 true_0!_A = 0 s_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 173 false_0!_A = 180 nil_0!_A = 183 if_low_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{181, x2 - 1, x3 + 168} if_high_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{177, x3 - 15} map_2!_A(x1,x2) = 184 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: quicksort_1#_A(x1) = 0 add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{42, x2 + 22} high_2_A(x1,x2) = max{16, x2 + 1} low_2_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 18 le_2_A(x1,x2) = 5 |0|_0_A = 11 true_0_A = 1 s_1_A(x1) = max{13, x1} false_0_A = 3 nil_0_A = 44 if_low_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{41, x3 + 18} if_high_3_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{24, x3 + 1} map_2_A(x1,x2) = max{44, x1 - 10} quicksort_1#!_A(x1) = max{0, x1 - 17} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = 8 high_2!_A(x1,x2) = 8 low_2!_A(x1,x2) = 48 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = 7 |0|_0!_A = 48 true_0!_A = 29 s_1!_A(x1) = 49 false_0!_A = 1 nil_0!_A = 29 if_low_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = 48 if_high_3!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{8, x1 + 2} map_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{29, x1 - 31, x2 - 45} partial status: pi(quicksort_1#) = [] pi(add_2) = [2] pi(high_2) = [2] pi(low_2) = [1, 2] pi(le_2) = [2] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(true_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(false_0) = [] pi(nil_0) = [] pi(if_low_3) = [2, 3] pi(if_high_3) = [3] pi(map_2) = [] The following rules are removed: p1, p2 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: app_2#(add_2(n,x),y) -> app_2#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of (no rules) Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: app_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 38} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 - 215, x2 + 37} app_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{3, x1 - 88, x2 - 1} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{2, x1 - 3, x2 - 88} 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: app_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 6} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 - 63, x2 + 5} app_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{5, x2 - 1} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{4, x1 - 344, x2 - 79} partial status: pi(app_2#) = [1] pi(add_2) = [2] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: high_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3#(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) p2: if_high_3#(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2#(n,x) p3: if_high_3#(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2#(n,x) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r35, r36, r37, r44 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: high_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 4, x2 - 32} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{30, x1 - 129, x2 + 28} if_high_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x1 - 11, x2 - 4, x3 - 33} le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{10, x1 - 150, x2 - 16} false_0_A = 10 true_0_A = 10 |0|_0_A = 15 s_1_A(x1) = max{17, x1 + 15} high_2_A(x1,x2) = max{10, x1 - 33, x2 - 33} nil_0_A = 0 high_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{13, x2 - 13} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{25, x1 + 24, x2 - 11} if_high_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{14, x3 - 40} le_2!_A(x1,x2) = 18 false_0!_A = 1 true_0!_A = 4 |0|_0!_A = 14 s_1!_A(x1) = max{18, x1 + 15} high_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{5, x1 - 164} nil_0!_A = 4 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: high_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 6, x2 - 8} add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{6, x1 - 60, x2 + 3} if_high_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x1 - 75, x2 - 6, x3 - 11} le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{74, x1 - 10, x2 - 10} false_0_A = 4 true_0_A = 0 |0|_0_A = 8 s_1_A(x1) = max{9, x1 + 7} high_2_A(x1,x2) = max{69, x1 - 26, x2 - 26} nil_0_A = 25 high_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 104} add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{68, x1 - 169, x2 - 71} if_high_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{68, x3 - 109} le_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{72, x1 - 62} false_0!_A = 69 true_0!_A = 3 |0|_0!_A = 4 s_1!_A(x1) = x1 + 70 high_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 - 198, x2 + 61} nil_0!_A = 3 partial status: pi(high_2#) = [] pi(add_2) = [2] pi(if_high_3#) = [] pi(le_2) = [1] pi(false_0) = [] pi(true_0) = [] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(high_2) = [] pi(nil_0) = [] The following rules are removed: p1, p2, p3 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: if_low_3#(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2#(n,x) p2: low_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3#(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) p3: if_low_3#(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2#(n,x) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r35, r36, r37, r40, r44 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: if_low_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x1 - 10, x2 - 238, x3 - 38} true_0_A = 9 add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{8, x1 - 317, x2 + 5} low_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 238, x2 - 33} le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{9, x1 - 340, x2 - 228} false_0_A = 0 |0|_0_A = 227 s_1_A(x1) = max{339, x1 + 227} low_2_A(x1,x2) = max{35, x1 - 239, x2 - 34} nil_0_A = 6 high_2_A(x1,x2) = max{28, x1 - 239, x2 - 34} if_low_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{6, x3 - 369} true_0!_A = 1 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{7, x2 - 362} low_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{6, x2 - 368} le_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{5, x1 - 328, x2 - 604} false_0!_A = 10 |0|_0!_A = 2 s_1!_A(x1) = 9 low_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{4, x1 - 605, x2 - 361} nil_0!_A = 3 high_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{7, x1 - 603, x2 - 7} 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: if_low_3#_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{0, x1 - 12, x2 - 22, x3 - 38} true_0_A = 7 add_2_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 - 45, x2 + 18} low_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 22, x2 - 20} le_2_A(x1,x2) = max{11, x1 - 53, x2 - 53} false_0_A = 5 |0|_0_A = 10 s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 6 low_2_A(x1,x2) = max{73, x1 - 17, x2 - 27} nil_0_A = 18 high_2_A(x1,x2) = max{28, x1 - 27, x2 - 21} if_low_3#!_A(x1,x2,x3) = 3 true_0!_A = 14 add_2!_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 5 low_2#!_A(x1,x2) = 3 le_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{15, x1 - 66} false_0!_A = 2 |0|_0!_A = 15 s_1!_A(x1) = 1 low_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{12, x1 - 66, x2 - 21} nil_0!_A = 8 high_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{9, x1 - 68, x2 - 21} partial status: pi(if_low_3#) = [3] pi(true_0) = [] pi(add_2) = [1, 2] pi(low_2#) = [2] pi(le_2) = [] pi(false_0) = [] pi(|0|_0) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(low_2) = [1] pi(nil_0) = [] pi(high_2) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1, p3 -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: low_2#(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3#(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: (no SCCs) -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: le_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of (no rules) Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: le_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 5, x2 - 5} s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 4 le_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{6, x1 - 239, x2 - 5} s_1!_A(x1) = max{5, x1 - 239} 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: le_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 5, x2 - 5} s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 4 le_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 5} s_1!_A(x1) = max{9, x1 - 15} partial status: pi(le_2#) = [2] pi(s_1) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: quot_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> quot_2#(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y)) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of r31, r32 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: quot_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 6, x2 - 5} s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 7 minus_2_A(x1,x2) = max{8, x1, x2 - 8} |0|_0_A = 3 quot_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{10, x2 + 8} s_1!_A(x1) = max{25, x1 + 16} minus_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{9, x1 - 462, x2 - 461} |0|_0!_A = 26 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: quot_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 39, x2 - 59} s_1_A(x1) = max{37, x1 + 21} minus_2_A(x1,x2) = x1 + 18 |0|_0_A = 21 quot_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 19} s_1!_A(x1) = max{23, x1 + 21} minus_2!_A(x1,x2) = max{38, x1 - 331, x2 - 37} |0|_0!_A = 24 partial status: pi(quot_2#) = [] pi(s_1) = [1] pi(minus_2) = [1, 2] pi(|0|_0) = [] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: minus_2#(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: |app'|(add_0(),y) -> add_1(y) r2: |app'|(add_1(x1),y) -> add_2(x1,y) r3: |app'|(app_0(),y) -> app_1(y) r4: |app'|(app_1(x1),y) -> app_2(x1,y) r5: |app'|(filter_0(),y) -> filter_1(y) r6: |app'|(filter_1(x1),y) -> filter_2(x1,y) r7: |app'|(filter2_0(),y) -> filter2_1(y) r8: |app'|(filter2_1(x1),y) -> filter2_2(x1,y) r9: |app'|(filter2_2(x1,x2),y) -> filter2_3(x1,x2,y) r10: |app'|(filter2_3(x1,x2,x3),y) -> filter2_4(x1,x2,x3,y) r11: |app'|(high_0(),y) -> high_1(y) r12: |app'|(high_1(x1),y) -> high_2(x1,y) r13: |app'|(if_high_0(),y) -> if_high_1(y) r14: |app'|(if_high_1(x1),y) -> if_high_2(x1,y) r15: |app'|(if_high_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_high_3(x1,x2,y) r16: |app'|(if_low_0(),y) -> if_low_1(y) r17: |app'|(if_low_1(x1),y) -> if_low_2(x1,y) r18: |app'|(if_low_2(x1,x2),y) -> if_low_3(x1,x2,y) r19: |app'|(le_0(),y) -> le_1(y) r20: |app'|(le_1(x1),y) -> le_2(x1,y) r21: |app'|(low_0(),y) -> low_1(y) r22: |app'|(low_1(x1),y) -> low_2(x1,y) r23: |app'|(map_0(),y) -> map_1(y) r24: |app'|(map_1(x1),y) -> map_2(x1,y) r25: |app'|(minus_0(),y) -> minus_1(y) r26: |app'|(minus_1(x1),y) -> minus_2(x1,y) r27: |app'|(quicksort_0(),y) -> quicksort_1(y) r28: |app'|(quot_0(),y) -> quot_1(y) r29: |app'|(quot_1(x1),y) -> quot_2(x1,y) r30: |app'|(s_0(),y) -> s_1(y) r31: minus_2(x,|0|_0()) -> x r32: minus_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> minus_2(x,y) r33: quot_2(|0|_0(),s_1(y)) -> |0|_0() r34: quot_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> s_1(quot_2(minus_2(x,y),s_1(y))) r35: le_2(|0|_0(),y) -> true_0() r36: le_2(s_1(x),|0|_0()) -> false_0() r37: le_2(s_1(x),s_1(y)) -> le_2(x,y) r38: app_2(nil_0(),y) -> y r39: app_2(add_2(n,x),y) -> add_2(n,app_2(x,y)) r40: low_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r41: low_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_low_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r42: if_low_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,low_2(n,x)) r43: if_low_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> low_2(n,x) r44: high_2(n,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r45: high_2(n,add_2(m,x)) -> if_high_3(le_2(m,n),n,add_2(m,x)) r46: if_high_3(true_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> high_2(n,x) r47: if_high_3(false_0(),n,add_2(m,x)) -> add_2(m,high_2(n,x)) r48: quicksort_1(nil_0()) -> nil_0() r49: quicksort_1(add_2(n,x)) -> app_2(quicksort_1(low_2(n,x)),add_2(n,quicksort_1(high_2(n,x)))) r50: map_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r51: map_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> add_2(|app'|(f,x),map_2(f,xs)) r52: filter_2(f,nil_0()) -> nil_0() r53: filter_2(f,add_2(x,xs)) -> filter2_4(|app'|(f,x),f,x,xs) r54: filter2_4(true_0(),f,x,xs) -> add_2(x,filter_2(f,xs)) r55: filter2_4(false_0(),f,x,xs) -> filter_2(f,xs) The set of usable rules consists of (no rules) Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >G) base order 1: trivial reduction triple (T x T, T x T, Φ) base order 2: lexicographic combination of reduction triples: 1. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: minus_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 11, x2 - 11} s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 10 minus_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 11, x2 - 11} s_1!_A(x1) = max{0, x1 - 1198} 2. marked-algebra reduction triple (>=A, >=A!, >A!): max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: minus_2#_A(x1,x2) = max{0, x1 - 5, x2 - 5} s_1_A(x1) = x1 + 4 minus_2#!_A(x1,x2) = max{15, x1 - 1339, x2 - 1340} s_1!_A(x1) = max{14, x1 - 1339} partial status: pi(minus_2#) = [2] pi(s_1) = [1] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains.