YES We show the termination of the TRS R: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) times(x,|1|()) -> x times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) plus(zero(),y) -> y plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) id(x) -> x if(true(),x,y) -> x if(false(),x,y) -> y not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() gt(zero(),y) -> false() gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: times#(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus#(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) p2: times#(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> times#(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))) p3: times#(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus#(y,times(|1|(),|0|())) p4: times#(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> times#(|1|(),|0|()) p5: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> plus#(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))) p6: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> if#(gt(x,y),x,y) p7: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> gt#(x,y) p8: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> if#(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y)) p9: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> not#(gt(x,y)) p10: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> id#(x) p11: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> id#(y) p12: plus#(s(x),x) -> plus#(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) p13: plus#(s(x),x) -> if#(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)) p14: plus#(s(x),x) -> gt#(x,x) p15: plus#(s(x),x) -> id#(x) p16: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> plus#(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y))) p17: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> if#(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)) p18: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> gt#(s(y),y) p19: not#(x) -> if#(x,false(),true()) p20: gt#(s(x),s(y)) -> gt#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: {p2} {p5, p12, p16} {p20} -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: times#(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> times#(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The set of usable rules consists of r3, r4, r5, r6, r7, r12, r13 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >MG) base order 1: max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: times#_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 51, x2 + 24} plus_A(x1,x2) = x2 + 54 |1|_A = 233 times_A(x1,x2) = max{101, x1 - 311, x2 - 131} |0|_A = 50 s_A(x1) = 0 if_A(x1,x2,x3) = 0 gt_A(x1,x2) = max{57, x1 - 7, x2 - 2} not_A(x1) = max{57, x1 - 67} id_A(x1) = 0 zero_A = 57 true_A = 56 false_A = 56 base order 2: precedence: times# > |1| > times = not > plus = s = gt = zero > |0| = id = true = false > if partial status: pi(times#) = [2] pi(plus) = [] pi(|1|) = [] pi(times) = [] pi(|0|) = [] pi(s) = [] pi(if) = [] pi(gt) = [] pi(not) = [] pi(id) = [] pi(zero) = [] pi(true) = [] pi(false) = [] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> plus#(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))) p2: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> plus#(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y))) p3: plus#(s(x),x) -> plus#(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The set of usable rules consists of r3, r8, r9, r10, r11, r12, r13, r14 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >MG) base order 1: max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: plus#_A(x1,x2) = max{x1 + 72, x2 + 70} s_A(x1) = max{157, x1 + 118} if_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{x1 - 145, x2 + 67, x3} gt_A(x1,x2) = max{71, x1 - 187, x2 - 187} not_A(x1) = max{68, x1 - 72} id_A(x1) = max{62, x1 + 47} times_A(x1,x2) = max{6, x1 - 184, x2 - 125} |0|_A = 4 true_A = 67 false_A = 0 zero_A = 68 base order 2: precedence: plus# > not > if > id > s = gt = zero > times = true = false > |0| partial status: pi(plus#) = [] pi(s) = [1] pi(if) = [2, 3] pi(gt) = [] pi(not) = [] pi(id) = [1] pi(times) = [] pi(|0|) = [] pi(true) = [] pi(false) = [] pi(zero) = [] The following rules are removed: p3 -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> plus#(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))) p2: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> plus#(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y))) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: {p1, p2} -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: plus#(s(x),s(y)) -> plus#(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))) p2: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> plus#(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y))) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The set of usable rules consists of r3, r8, r9, r10, r11, r12, r13, r14 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >MG) base order 1: max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: plus#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 13, x2 - 20} s_A(x1) = x1 + 18 if_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{12, x2 + 2, x3} gt_A(x1,x2) = max{57, x1 - 69, x2 - 51} not_A(x1) = max{56, x1 - 108} id_A(x1) = x1 + 4 times_A(x1,x2) = max{38, x1 - 40, x2 - 79} |0|_A = 6 true_A = 17 false_A = 0 zero_A = 18 base order 2: precedence: gt > plus# > s = not = id = zero > if = true = false > times > |0| partial status: pi(plus#) = [] pi(s) = [1] pi(if) = [3] pi(gt) = [] pi(not) = [] pi(id) = [1] pi(times) = [] pi(|0|) = [] pi(true) = [] pi(false) = [] pi(zero) = [] The following rules are removed: p1 -- SCC decomposition. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> plus#(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y))) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The estimated dependency graph contains the following SCCs: {p1} -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: plus#(id(x),s(y)) -> plus#(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y))) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The set of usable rules consists of r3, r12, r13 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >MG) base order 1: max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: plus#_A(x1,x2) = max{4, x1 + 2} id_A(x1) = max{18, x1 + 3} s_A(x1) = max{7, x1 - 144} if_A(x1,x2,x3) = max{6, x1 - 9, x2 - 217, x3 - 73} gt_A(x1,x2) = max{6, x1 - 64, x2 - 208} times_A(x1,x2) = max{41, x1 - 44, x2 - 20} |0|_A = 40 zero_A = 63 true_A = 5 false_A = 5 base order 2: precedence: times > |0| > plus# = s > if = gt = zero > id = true = false partial status: pi(plus#) = [1] pi(id) = [1] pi(s) = [] pi(if) = [] pi(gt) = [] pi(times) = [] pi(|0|) = [] pi(zero) = [] pi(true) = [] pi(false) = [] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains. -- Reduction pair. Consider the dependency pair problem (P, R), where P consists of p1: gt#(s(x),s(y)) -> gt#(x,y) and R consists of: r1: times(x,plus(y,|1|())) -> plus(times(x,plus(y,times(|1|(),|0|()))),x) r2: times(x,|1|()) -> x r3: times(x,|0|()) -> |0|() r4: plus(s(x),s(y)) -> s(s(plus(if(gt(x,y),x,y),if(not(gt(x,y)),id(x),id(y))))) r5: plus(s(x),x) -> plus(if(gt(x,x),id(x),id(x)),s(x)) r6: plus(zero(),y) -> y r7: plus(id(x),s(y)) -> s(plus(x,if(gt(s(y),y),y,s(y)))) r8: id(x) -> x r9: if(true(),x,y) -> x r10: if(false(),x,y) -> y r11: not(x) -> if(x,false(),true()) r12: gt(s(x),zero()) -> true() r13: gt(zero(),y) -> false() r14: gt(s(x),s(y)) -> gt(x,y) The set of usable rules consists of r3, r6, r12, r13 Take the reduction pair: generalized weighted path order (>=MG, >MG) base order 1: max/plus interpretation on natural numbers: gt#_A(x1,x2) = max{1, x1 - 7, x2 - 10} s_A(x1) = max{9, x1 + 6} times_A(x1,x2) = max{36, x1 - 71} |0|_A = 2 plus_A(x1,x2) = max{35, x2} zero_A = 8 gt_A(x1,x2) = max{8, x1 - 10, x2 - 10} true_A = 7 false_A = 7 base order 2: precedence: gt# > s = times = plus = zero = gt > |0| = true = false partial status: pi(gt#) = [] pi(s) = [1] pi(times) = [] pi(|0|) = [] pi(plus) = [2] pi(zero) = [] pi(gt) = [] pi(true) = [] pi(false) = [] The following rules are removed: p1 Then no dependency pair remains.