YES # parallel critical pair closing system (Shintani and Hirokawa 2022) Consider the left-linear TRS R: f(a(),a()) -> b() a() -> a'() f(a'(),x) -> f(x,x) f(x,a'()) -> f(x,x) f(a'(),a'()) -> b() b() -> f(a'(),a'()) Let C be the following subset of R: a() -> a'() b() -> f(a'(),a'()) The TRS R is left-linear and all parallel critical pairs are joinable by C. Therefore, the confluence of R follows from that of C. # parallel critical pair closing system (Shintani and Hirokawa 2022) Consider the left-linear TRS R: a() -> a'() b() -> f(a'(),a'()) Let C be the following subset of R: (empty) The TRS R is left-linear and all parallel critical pairs are joinable by C. Therefore, the confluence of R follows from that of C. # emptiness The empty TRS is confluent.