YES 1: +(0(),x1) -> x1 2: +(s(x2),x1) -> s(+(x2,x1)) 3: dbl(x2) -> +(x2,x2) 4: +(+(x2,x1),x3) -> +(x2,+(x1,x3)) 5: +(x2,x1) -> +(x1,x2) @Jouannaud and Kirchner's criterion --- R 1: +(0(),x1) -> x1 2: +(s(x2),x1) -> s(+(x2,x1)) 3: dbl(x2) -> +(x2,x2) 4: +(+(x2,x1),x3) -> +(x2,+(x1,x3)) 5: +(x2,x1) -> +(x1,x2) --- S 1: +(0(),x1) -> x1 2: +(s(x2),x1) -> s(+(x2,x1)) 3: dbl(x2) -> +(x2,x2) 4: +(+(x2,x1),x3) -> +(x2,+(x1,x3)) 5: +(x2,x1) -> +(x1,x2)